Why Numerical Relativity?

Calculating Physics

Einstein gave us a beautiful, and — in some sense — very elegant description of physics with his equation

$$G = 8πT.$$

This basic equation encodes all of gravity; it forms the most essential piece of the puzzle in any understanding of the physical world. In principle, if we know everything on both sides of this equation at one moment in time, we can use it figure out everything at all moments in time. That is, we can figure out what the shape of spacetime (Spacetime: A concept in physics which merges our usual notion of space with our usual notion of time.) is, where all the matter is, and where it is going. Unfortunately, this elegant form of the equation is almost completely useless for doing calculations. In order to accomplish anything, a physicist intending to use Einstein's Equations (Einstein's Equations: A set of "tensor" equations Einstein devised to describe how mass warps spacetime. The set of equations may be written as $$G = 8 π T$$, where both $$G$$ and $$T$$ each represent a set of ten quantities. The $$G$$ quantities represent the warping of spacetime, while the $$T$$ quantities — the "Stress-Energy tensor" represent the mass.) must begin a very complicated analysis, involving huge amounts of algebra and calculus.

The Difficulties of Solving Einstein's Equations

For most problems, physicists need to use the same equation above in a fuller form. There are ten distinct equations that come out of this. By using a few abbreviations, we can make things look comparatively nice, and fit this more full form on one page. (See the box below.) Conceptually, the equations just describe the change in the metric (Metric: A set of numbers which encodes information about the geometry of space or spacetime. Together with an understanding of how that information is encoded (using Coordinates) everything about the geometry can be understood.) from point to point. They do it in a pretty complicated way, though. Unfortunately, this is how Einstein's equations must be used if we want to tackle real-world problems and figure out actual answers with them.

To write the easy form of Einstein's equations, we first define a new set of numbers:

$$\Gamma^\alpha_{\beta\gamma} = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{\delta =x,y,z,t}g^{\alpha \delta }\biggl(\frac{\partial g_{\delta\beta}}{\partial x^{\gamma}} + \frac{\partial g_{\delta\gamma}}{\partial x^{\beta}}-\frac{\partial g_{\beta\gamma}}{\partial x^{\delta}}\biggr)$$

The Greek letters $$\alpha$$, $$\beta$$, $$\gamma$$, and $$\delta$$ can each be replaced by any of the letters $$x$$, $$y$$, $$z$$, or $$t$$. The $$\Sigma$$ symbol is a sum. The symbol $$g^{\alpha \delta }$$ is essentially the same thing as the metric, $$g_{\alpha \delta }$$, but with slightly different numbers. Terms like $$\frac{\partial g_{\delta\beta}}{\partial x^{\gamma}}$$ represent the change in the metric from point to point along the lines of our coordinate grid. With this definition, Einstein's equations become

\begin{align}8πT_{\alpha\beta} = &\sum_{\delta} \Bigg[\frac{\partial\Gamma^\delta_{\alpha\beta}}{\partial x^\delta} - \frac{\partial\Gamma^\delta_{\delta\beta}}{\partial x^\alpha} + \sum_{\gamma} (\Gamma^\delta_{\alpha\beta} \Gamma^\gamma_{\delta\gamma} - \Gamma^\delta_{\gamma\beta} \Gamma^\gamma_{\delta\alpha})\Bigg] \\&- \frac{1}{2} g_{\alpha\beta} \sum_{\delta}\sum_{\gamma} \Bigg\{g^{\delta\gamma}\sum_{\mu} \Bigg[ \frac{\partial\Gamma^\mu_{\delta\gamma}}{\partial x^\mu} - \frac{\partial\Gamma^\mu_{\mu\gamma}}{\partial x^\delta} + \sum_{\gamma} (\Gamma^\mu_{\delta\gamma} \Gamma^\nu_{\mu\nu} - \Gamma^\mu_{\nu\gamma} \Gamma^\nu_{\mu\delta})\Bigg] \Bigg\}\end{align}

Since the Greek letters are standing in for real letters, there are actually sixteen copies of these equations! Granted, six of those are unnecessary, but that's still a lot of equations. And, we're using abbreviations. To write all of these ten equations out in terms of the metric alone - without any abbreviations - would take roughly a hundred pages! If this doesn't seem very "easy" to you, you are not alone.

Now, in some situations, these complicated equations can be simplified. For instance, if we are looking at empty space with no matter in it, the Stress-Energy tensor (the $$T$$ above) disappears, so one side of Einstein's equations is just zero. If the Universe is the same in every direction, no matter which way you look, all but two of Einstein's equations disappear. In many interesting physical situations, these types of simplifications are good enough to describe the real Universe quite well. These tricks allow us to understand what must have happened following the Big Bang (Big Bang: An astrophysical theory of the beginning of the Universe. It suggests that the Universe began in a very tiny region of space, and exploded outward. Astrophysicists believe that this occurred roughly 14 billion years ago. Other astrophysical theories for the beginning of the Universe — like the Braneworld theory — exist, though none is as thoroughly studied and supported by the data as the Big Bang model. Scientists have no idea what came before the Big Bang.).

The space around a quiet, non-spinning Black Hole (Black Hole: A region of spacetime where the warpage of both space and time (gravity) is so intense that nothing — even light — can ever escape. Objects may fall in to the Black Hole, but once they pass the Event Horizon (Event Horizon: A surface — like the one surrounding a Black Hole — enclosing a region of space from which nothing (even light) can ever escape.), they can never escape again. Most Black Holes (Black Hole: A region of spacetime where the warpage of both space and time (gravity) is so intense that nothing — even light — can ever escape. Objects may fall in to the Black Hole, but once they pass the Event Horizon, they can never escape again. Most Black Holes believed to exist are thought to be formed in the collapse of very large stars, or the collision of stars or other Black Holes. )})|blackholes}) believed to exist are thought to be formed in the collapse of very large stars, or the collision of stars or other Black Holes. ) is simple enough that it was first analyzed and understood by a German soldier serving on the Eastern front during World War I, just months after Einstein introduced his equations to the world. Conditions were grim; the soldier died shortly after writing to Einstein describing his discovery. Nonetheless, he was able to solve Einstein's Equations in these circumstances, using just pencil and paper.

If gravity is weak, most of the terms in Einstein's equations are quite small, and so can be ignored. This — along with the knowledge of a few more tricks — allows us to analyze gravitational waves (Gravitational Wave: A gravitational disturbance that travels through space like a wave. This type of wave is analogous to an Electromagnetic Wave. Gravitational waves are given off by most movements of anything with mass. Usually, however, they are quite difficult to detect. Physicists are currently working hard to directly detect gravitational waves. Experiments like LIGO and LISA are designed for this purpose. ) with Einstein's equations. The analysis is not perfect, since it is only an approximation, but it is a very precise approximation, and the errors from the perfect solution are tiny.

Of course, not all of Nature is quite so simple. If we want to know what Einstein's equations say about two black holes with different masses falling into each other, for example, we have to use every one of the terms in all ten of the equations. There are no simplifications that Nature will respect in this case. In this state of affairs, Relativity as a tool for understanding interesting physics seems hopelessly lost. There are too many equations, with far too many terms, for any human to even keep track of — never mind solve.

The Initial-Value Formulation and Computers to the Rescue

In their form above, Einstein's equations have to be solved everywhere throughout spacetime, all at once. Thankfully, methods have been found which allow us to just solve on one slice of space (no time), and them step forward in time from there.

The Achievements Possible with Numerical Relativity (Numerical Relativity: The branch of Relativity research which deals with simulating the development of Spacetime, using computers. This is believed to be the only possible way to understand things like the merger of two Black Holes.)

Templates for GW observatories make these observations possible. New physics, bringing us greater understanding of the implications of Einstein's equations.